1. It smelled weird.

2. It was clumpy.

3. It was indeed waterproof, but it was also stiff and sticky.

Verdict: it went in the trash after two wearings.

I’m back to my Clinique free-with-purchase mascara (not waterproof, but it has a nice full brush and it makes my lashes look long and thick) and I’m combing through your suggestions.

I’m also dishing about what to wear for the holidays at BlogHer.

Now who else wants to suggest some mascara?

Edited to add: This was really Take Two; I started with the Dior mascara that I returned to Sephora (good work with the return policy, Sephora!) because it was smudging all over my face. Also, I am making note of your recommendations and will continue to report back.

Because god knows I don’t have anything better to do with my time.